
Bowl of Smoke photo by Melanie Cook
A few years back, imperfect strangers would stop me in the grocery store and give me advice. On everything. My looks, my clothes, my love life, my purchases. Everything. If one more person had told me what I should do with my life, I would have exploded. I was caught up in the adversity of advice-ty, and I just couldn’t take it anymore.“I can’t believe that just happened,” a friend said after witnessing one of these interactions. “Why in the world would a complete stranger ever say that to another person? She didn’t know you or anything about you, but she sure told you how to live your life.”
I wondered that, too, but more recently, I’ve wondered why it stopped more suddenly than it started. What I learned was that the change wasn’t in the world around me but in me, and I realized that, yes, there are some ways to stop getting fire-hosed with advice that drives you crazy.
1. Stop asking for it.
I mean stop LITERALLY asking for advice. When I came out of a long-term marriage, I had to rebuild myself from the ground up. There were areas of my life that were very solid, such as my knowledge of my career field. I rarely asked for advice about work because I didn’t need it. I knew what I was doing. But when it came to being on my own for the first time in a couple of decades? Not just alone, but alone and responsible for my kids as well? I felt I couldn’t afford to make mistakes. I needed tools for dealing with my situation, especially in areas where I’d botched previous relationships, so I asked for help in understanding what was happening and what my options were.
And friends, colleagues, family, and strangers were more than happy to give me their opinions. I needed reinforcement much of the time, validation that I was making a good decision, verification that I was doing something right after feeling for years that I did only the wrong things. But at some point, the advice became overwhelming, and solicited advice turned too quickly into unsolicited advice that was overbearing. Some people just couldn’t stop giving it, long after I didn’t need it or want it. I’d opened a door I couldn’t seem to shut and far too many people took the parental role in doling out their advice on situations that were no longer in need of more analysis or help.
I stopped asking advice of anyone new, except in certain situations where I paid for professional advice, but the overwhelming and now unwanted “friendly” advice was suffocating me with negativity and causing me to questions things I felt good and right about–and that left me hurt, angry, full of doubt, and overwhelmed. And yet, even though I was no longer asking for advice in a literal sense, people whom I’d never laid eyes on sought me out to tell me what “you should do” or “you need to do” or “you ought to do.” No, what I really NEEDED to do was…
2. Stop broadcasting.
I had run into Kmart for some cleaning supplies when I noticed a sale in the garden department. Unfortunately, most of the plants had been picked over and a few were in need of a little care, including a specific variety of plant I really wanted and couldn’t find locally. I paused over the battered plants for a few minutes, trying to decide if they were worth the 75%-off price and how quickly I could nurse them to lushness with my vividly green thumbs. I reluctantly decided to buy the plants but my biggest worry was whether my upcoming two-week trip would hinder their rejuvenation. I was still fretting over it mentally when I rounded the corner with my cart and a stranger stared at me and then wheeled her cart to block me.
“Why are you buying those?” she demanded. “You’re settling for the dregs that they can’t get rid of otherwise. Those plants are half-dead and you’ll never be able to revive them. You’re wasting your money.”
Her diatribe went on for another few minutes before I, somewhat flustered and trying to figure out if I knew her, told her I was buying them anyway and she then wheeled away angrily. Long after I’d resurrected the el-cheapo plants that I couldn’t find elsewhere and nourished them to lovely shrubs in my garden, I was still bothered by her sudden explosion of advice.
That day, I was unsure of the decision I was making, and being the open-book I tend to be with my emotions, ideas, and decisions, I was broadcasting my uncertainty, full-blast. It was probably in my body language if not in my aura. What I’ve discovered is that if you are less than confident about any area of your life, people will step in to fill what they perceive as a void of information and certainty for you–even if they fill it with garbage. Sometimes this is out of concern, but it can also be a power-trip for them or a chance to feel better about their own issues if they can tell themselves–and you–how much better off they are than you. Their unsolicited advice is a result of their own self-importance and self-esteem and has nothing to do with you except that you’re a blank canvas that is radiating insecurity in some area.
Though it was quite common, I found it incredibly easy for one particular colleague who had been married for 20 years–and hadn’t dated around in 25–to advise me on dating after divorce, not realizing that things have changed a little bit since her college days. Part of it was living vicariously though my social life, since she wasn’t terribly happy in her own troubled marriage but felt she was definitely better off than poor, divorced Lorna. Because this situation repeated itself so often, I finally learned to…
3. Tell people what you need.
Early on, when I was unsure of so many things as I re-emerged in the world of single women, I explicitly asked for advice because I didn’t know which direction to take. I needed information then. As I began to work through the information and make decisions, my needs shifted. It wasn’t so much information that I needed as a sounding board and, sometimes, just someone to vent to.
I had certain friends I could call and say, “Hey, I just need to talk through this out loud because I’ve already talked through it in my head a billion times and it doesn’t make sense.” This has worked quite well for me with two life coaches I’ve employed for different reasons (I’ve also fired coaches for failing in this area and letting their personal feelings color their advice). I hired Yoda because I needed 100% objectivity and confidentiality in talking through some life transition issues that I couldn’t talk to other friends about. There were times when I glimpsed some struggle on her face and knew she thought I should handle the situation differently, but instead of giving me advice based on what was right for HER life, she kept quiet and asked probing questions that helped me get to the best spot for me. My other coach was specifically an advisor but kept her personal opinions to herself if she disagreed with the direction I chose. She has on one or two occasions offered her personal opinion but caveated her comments as being her personal opinion and just one of many options available to me. In both cases, these were advisors who were respectful of my needs and didn’t force their own opinions on me. When I asked for advice, both cheerfully gave it. When I asked for a sounding board, both were there for me. When I asked for emotional support regarding a decision, I got that, too.
But telling someone what you need doesn’t always work. Sometimes you have to…
4. Tell people what you don’t need.
Let’s use the analogy of telling a friend not to squeeze your arm when they see you because you have a deep wound there and you’re choosing to let it heal in a particular way so please don’t give medical advice or try to re-bandage it in a different way. Does the friend instead pat your back gently and tell you she’ll be careful not to bump your injured arm? Or does she rip off the bandage and pick at the wound and tell you which ointments to use?
Two long-lost friends came back into my life at about the same time but separately, and we caught up on what had happened in our lives over the months–in one case–and decades–in the other case–since we’d been close. I told them both about a particular situation in my life at that time and said, “I’m telling you this so that you understand why I’m doing certain things and don’t ask questions I’m not emotionally prepared to answer. I’m not seeking advice on how to handle it and I specifically do not want anyone’s opinions on how I’m choosing to deal with this issue. I welcome your emotional support if you choose to give it, but my decisions on this are not open for discussion so please don’t give me advice on how you would handle it. This is something in my life that you can’t handle for me and I’m the only one who has to.”
I was very clear in what I didn’t need–advice and probing questions.
After being told specifically NOT to give me advice on this one issue–I needed to decide entirely on my own without anyone else’s influence–my two old friends handled it oppositely. One, who had a prior pattern of coming to me for career advice, was a little hurt that I refused to hear her opinion on any subject at all but thought it through and understood why I needed support without criticism. To this day, she and I are close friends and she has never prodded me about the decision I made.
My other friend, who was older and had adopted me in college, had a pattern decades ago of giving me big sisterly advice. She ignored my request and immediately gave me a harsh lecture on what I should do. Which is why I had to learn to…
5. Cut people off when they don’t respect your boundaries.
I asked her a second time not to pursue it and reiterated that I was informing her of the situation, not asking her how to live it, and to please not continue discussing it. I didn’t have to tell her at all but for old times’ sake, I wanted her to know why I would and wouldn’t be involved in her life in certain ways.
Again, she ignored my request and came back with how she would handle it and how I should handle it and what was best for me, even though she hadn’t been in my life in many, many years and had no idea of much of what had happened in the intervening years. Her lack of respect for this particular boundary I’d established was upsetting and it took several days for me to calm myself about her thoughtless comments. I knew she didn’t mean to be hurtful but the fact that she wouldn’t leave it alone was scraping at a delicate and painful wound that needed time to heal. When I felt able to discuss it again, I told her explicitly that the subject was not up for advisement and if she persisted in giving me advice that I found intrusive and domineering, then I would not be able to keep the friendship we’d revived.
The last I heard from her was an email saying that of course she wouldn’t dump her opinions on me if I didn’t want but she was just concerned and what I really needed to do was…and what I ought to do was…and what I should do was…. Yeah. After so many years of being apart, we could have renewed the friendship very nicely but for her, being the expert advisor was a source of personal power and self-importance, and it was only the tip of the iceberg. I had to turn the boundary I’d set into a wall, but the barrage of “I know what you need even though you obviously don’t” would never have improved.
The ironic thing was, for as good as she was at doling out advice, she was absolutely miserable in a similar situation that I’d seen play out in her life at least thrice and she was really screwed up at the time she came back into my life. But then, as my daughter once told me during a difficult period in my life…
6. Never take advice from unhappy people.
Unhappy people seem loaded with expert advice on what it takes to be happy or successful or whatever it is that eludes them. They’re talented at telling others exactly what will make life wonderful, yet they’ve never achieved wonderful–or never sustained it–for very long. You might think they’re ecstatic from all that knowledge of what really works, but most of the time, their advice is their fantasy or their failure.
In the case of my two coaches (the one I hired and not the ones I fired), both were serene, calm, overall happy people. They had their own problems, yes, but they were what I would qualify as “mostly content.” I’ve talked to relationship coaches who were pleasantly engaged in long-term relationships with partners they considered to be their best friends and they gave sane and smart advice to their clients. I’ve talked to colleagues who were prosperous and well-grounded, and so was their advice. I learned the hard way something that makes so much sense: take advice from people who have successfully navigated your troubled waters to a place of contentment, whether it’s a relationship, finances, career, or family. If you let yourself get in a situation where you are taking advice from negative people, then nothing positive will come from it.
Not only that, but…
7. If you reject advice, be prepared for unpleasant feedback.
I’ve heard some people say that they owe an advice-giver a listen because that person is showing they care. Maybe they do care. Maybe not. Who really knows what they get out of giving you advice? I’ve heard others say they owed an advice-giver a listen because that advisor was investing time in their lives. So what? If it’s unsolicited advice, you don’t owe them a listen. You may choose to listen for a few minutes or even hours or not at all or every time they cross your path, but you don’t owe anyone for unsolicited advice. They choose to give it.
You’re also not obligated to follow through on advice you’re given, whether it’s unsolicited or you asked for it.
As for solicited advice, if you’re not paying for it, thank the other person for their time. If you decide not to follow through with their advice after they’ve spent time with you, you may wish to let them know you’ve considered all the factors and decided to go in a different direction this time but you appreciate them being there for you. Their reaction may or not be gracious.
Don’t be surprised, though, if the advisor becomes angry at you for not taking his or her advice, whether it’s solicited or not. If they find out later that you didn’t take their advice, they’ll likely be perturbed. If you tell them pointblank that you’re not going to take their advice, they’ll be even more perturbed. Advisors, even professional counselors, often take your response to their advice personally.
The best way I’ve found of dealing with rejecting advice (especially unsolicited advice from acquaintances and strangers) is a simple, “Thank you for your feedback on that!” Prepare for unwanted advice by having a catch-phrase ready that acknowledges their opinion, doesn’t commit you, and allows them to trot away happily to be a busy-body elsewhere while you trot away happily to ignore how they think you should live your life.
So why have things changed now, so that I don’t seem to attract all this unwanted advice? Simple. When I was pregnant with Shannon, my first child, I wanted to hide during most of my pregnancy because I got so much unsolicited advice. Some small portion was good but most of it seemed designed to terrorize me: the 60 hours of labor, the wish-you-were-dead pain of childbirth, the change in lifestyle that would make you wish you’d never conceived, how awful it would be to work fulltime and how someone’s cousin’s sister-in-law dropped their baby on its head while bathing it. Most was meant well, but it was absolutely awful. I spent most of those 9 months scared to death and terribly uncertain about what I’d gotten myself into. There was the idiot waitress who asked my husband if it was okay when I ordered a Coke to soothe my morning sickness and the lectures I got from strangers.
Fast-forward to a couple of years later, when Aislinn was conceived and I didn’t tell anyone until I was five months along and couldn’t hide it anymore. I was in no mood for hours of advice per day. I looked about the same as when I’d been pregnant with Shannon. I worked with new people who didn’t know me before. I was just as active. There was really no visible difference, and yet only twice during my entire pregnancy with Aislinn did anyone give me advice. A few people asked if it was my “first” and then shut up. Most just didn’t bother with the horror stories.
The difference? With my second child, I knew what I was up against for the pregnancy (even though it was quite different), the labor, and the delivery (also very different). I carried myself with a confidence that dis-invited anyone to tell me what to do, though I didn’t even know it at the time.
And that’s what’s happened over the last six months or so. I’ve reached a point of knowing which path to take and that I won’t be deterred and no one need waste their breath. There’s no longer a void to be perceived that a stranger must fill with advice that doesn’t really fit my life at all. And if they simply must say something silly to me like, “You haven’t remarried yet? You just need to [fill in the blank],” then I’m most likely to laugh and say, “Oh, I don’t think so!” c Lorna Tedder